Entering my third year as a Phillies fan, excitement surrounding the team is at a high not seen for a long time. Shortstop Jimmy Rollins has said the Phillies are the "team to beat in the NL East this year." Here is my position by position breakdown headed into the 2007 season.
Note: The bulk of this was written after the first two games - two games blown by the bullpen in extra innings.
First Base: Controlled by reigning NL MVP Ryan Howard. Howard is obviously the team's best power hitter and fan favorite. His defense still needs some work, but he can't be perfect in every area. He batted cleanup last year, but has moved to third in the order for 2007. Not a move I am in total agreement with, though they seem to have switched him back to 4th now. Probably won't put up the same numbers as last year, but Howard will have another monster year, despite his slow start. GRADE A
Second Base: Chase Utley could have been the Phillies MVP last year. He is the best hitting second baseman in all of baseball and an All-Star for years to come. He plays average defense, but makes the plays he has to. Probably the Phillie you would most want up to bat in a clutch situation. GRADE A
Shortstop: Jimmy Rollins is probably the leader of the team, and put a bullseye on the team and himself when he declared in the off-season that the Phillies "are the team to beat in the NL East." Rollins is an outstanding defender. Some question whether or not he is a good leadoff hitter, but he is the best they have to do the job. He is also a clutch player who has a knack for coming up with big stolen bases. GRADE A-
Third Base: Wes Helms was signed to be the everyday third baseman. He started five times there last year for the Marlins. He is suspect at best on defense, but should provide a defensive boost over the man who played third for most of last season, David Bell. Abraham Nunez will come in to takeover for defensive in close games in the late innings. Backup Greg Dobbs will also see some time here. The Phillies will likely go with the hottest bat throughout the season. GRADE C
Left Field: To put it nicely, Pat Burrell is not a fan favorite. Burrell has a well earned reputation for coming up empty when it matters the most and his range in the outfield can only be described as terrible. Every time he makes an out, he is booed. He was shopped around all winter, but no other team wants want him at $13 million a year; in fact most teams probably wouldn't want him for half of that. Two teams did show interest, but Burrell used his power to veto the trades, which is surprising, considering he has almost no support in Philly. He has to have a better year than he did last year in the 5 slot in the batting order for this team to go deep. GRADE CCenter Field: Aaron Rowand will also be fondly remembered for his face first catch against the wall last year when he broke his nose. However, Rowand has not been the hitter the Phillies thought they were getting when they acquired him prior to the 2006 season from the White Sox. He is above average in the outfield. GRADE B-
Right Field: Coupled with the other two, the speedy ShaneVictorino as the everyday right fielder makes the Phillies outfield one of the lightest in all of the National League. Victorino has a cannon in right and teams are leery of running on him on balls hit his way. Can he be an everyday player is the big question here. I think he can. GRADE B-
Catcher: The team decided not to resign Mike Lieberthal, and went after Rangers catcher Rod Barajas, a move I am skeptical of - I think the money could have been better spent. The backup is Carlos Ruiz, who I have just as much confidence in. Neither one strikes particular fear into the opponents hitting wise, but both are solid behind the plate. GRADE C+
Bench: Right now the reserves are: Dobbs, Nunez, Jayson Werth, Michael Bourn (a speedy OF), and Ruiz. An average bench, but probably better than most NL teams. I would like to see someone with more speed added to the roster for late game situations. Last year's late season callup, Chris Coste is currently on the DL, but there might not be a space for him when he does come back. Werth, a right handed batter, could be a productive 4th outfielder if Burrell struggles. Werth has not been able to stay healthy in his career. GRADE B
Starting Rotation: This is an area that at least on paper has been improved from last year. Brett Myers was the Opening Day starter, and I look for him to have a monster year. Cole Hamels came up midway through last year and he is going to be a dominate pitcher for years to come in Philadelphia if he can stay healthy. Freddy Garcia was acquired from the White Sox. The big question with him is fastball velocity. Baseball folks are whispering that he has lost some zip on that pitch. Jamie Moyer, who was brought to the team via trade last August is a very solid #4 man who still has a lot left to offer, both on the mound and mentoring the young pitchers of the Phils. Adam Eaton rounds out the rotation. Eaton has never been able to stay off the DL and frankly I think this was wasted money. He looked dreadful in Spring Training. Better than last year, but still some question mark with this bunch. GRADE B
Bullpen: The biggest question mark on the team. Ryan Madson will be the set-up man, and he has looked great in the spring (but blew the game on Opening Day in extra innings and helped the downfall in Game 2). He won't be a starter this year, as that experiment has ended for the best. Geoff Geary and Antonio Alfonseca will be the right handers that work the 6th and 7th inning. Matt Smith will be the main situational lefty. Former starter Jon Lieber will also start the year in the bullpen (and the DL), but he will either be traded for bullpen help or moved back to the rotation if there is an injury before long. The bullpen is the key - they blew a ton of games for the starters last year. GRADE C
Closer: Tom Gordon staying healthy is a big key to the season. He will not pitch 3 days in a row this season. He has looked good in Spring Training. Gordon allows to many runners for my liking, but he usually gets the job done. I am not sure he has ever had a 1-2-3 inning. As I was typing this, he blew the save in the second game of this season. GRADE C+
Manager: A big year for manager Charlie Manuel. It is playoffs or bust this year, and Manuel is in the final year of his contract. Never a fan favorite in Philadelphia, Manuel has made some moves that have not pleased the fans, which is surprising because he is the best manager in baseball. GRADE A+Broadcasting: In the off-season, the team fired lead radio play by play man Scott Graham, in a move that was very disturbing to me, since Graham is the only "Voice of the Phillies" I have ever known - through listening to all games on the internet. The new man in the booth is former Phil Gary Matthews, aka The Sarge. Apparently, The Sarge didn't have to audition, as he sounds like he is speaking into a napkin at the lowest voice level possible. The rest of the radio team is rounded out by the very bland Scott Franzke (who only did the 5th and 6th innings and pre and postgame last year) and former pitcher Larry Andersen, who many people don't care for, but I like and think is funny. TV will be held down by the legendary Harry Kalas (does voice over work for NFL Films and Thursday Night Football) and Chris Wheeler, Kalas's mortal enemy. The two TV men legitimately hate each others guts. Good times. GRADE D
Prediction: 91-71, first place in the NL East.


